OpenStack meetup

16th June 2018, I attended OpenStack Meetup at Ericsson office. Let me share my notes for readers of this blog : Express YourSelf !

Shashi Singh from Altiostar Networks discussed about EPA (Enhanced Platform Awareness). 

EPA is about about making aware NFVO, VNFM and VIM, that specialized hardware is available below virtualization layer. E.g. High I/O throughput, high performance CPU, GPU, crupto accelerators and many more as below slides:

Shashi explained nicely NFV MANO architecture to build the context and introducing the acronmys. Telco NFVI providers are: RedHat, WindRiver, VMWare, Mirantis etc. VNFM is categorized as specific VNFM and Generic VNFM. It supports three interfaces: Ve-Vnfm-vnf, Vi-Vnfm and Or-Vnfm.

He explained how EPA can eliminate the need of passing through virtualization layer for data packet, if the required VNFs are running at same CPU socket. I confirmed my understanding that, one example of EPA is let all VNFs for user-plane data having single CPU afinity. We also discussed about SR-IOV single root input/output virtualization, cpu pinning, threading policy etc. Sometimes within storage node, one can leaverage use of SR-IOV, DPDK etc to support more I/O. TOSCA standard defines combination of NS-D (Network Service Descriptor) and VNFD (VNF Descriptor). Shashi also mentioend about Queens Release, Cyborg framework, nova, ironic etc. 

Ercisson people mentioned about Ericsson portfolio containing all components of NFV MANO, that is essential for 5G network deployment and its progress with its customers (mobile operators). I came to know about this website During tea-break, someone commented, that Kubernetes is now open source, but it is very old. Google is working on new technology / product named by Omega that is yet to be open sourced. 

Palaniswamy from Tech M, explains about ManageIQ (with demostration) as Multi Cloud Management Platform. ManageIQ supports public clouds like : Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud Platform; OpenStack based private clouds; containers like Kubernetes, OpenShift Origin etc. ManageIQ internally uses PostgreSQL DB. Ansible Tower is used for configuration and automation. 

Sukant J R and Manoranjan Sahoo from Ericsson presented about CI/CD for containerized openstack development based on Helm. 

We also discussed about 4 types of people in IT industry always remains. (1) Developers (2) Support engineers (3) Integrators and (4) Testers. The new technology comes and goes. One needs to work, as per his/her core strength. 

Apart from that, Uday T.Kumar from Ericsson shared some insights about OpenStack Summit and how to contribute to OpenStack community. He also acknowledged that Bangalore OpenStack community is very active and sharing the latest updates. Later on those updates are known to entire world at OpenStack summit. 

Disclaimer: I captured this notes, as per my understanding on best effor basis. So it may not accurately refelct the spearker's view. Any corrections are welcome.  


My Holiday Destination

HDH Mahant Swami Maharaj @ Bangalore

Jai SwamiNarayan

Recently, HDH Mahant Swami Maharaj visited Bangalore. All followers of BAPS SwamiNarayan religion were super excited with full of devotion. If one remains in the presence of such divine Saint, even for short time, he/she get huge benefits in all fronts. I was lucky enough to get His blessings and listen to His speeches. He emphasize on importance of unity among all followers/volunteers for great success. 

One of BAPS followers planned to sing Kirtan/Bhajan/rhyme in different languages : Hindi, Panjabi, Gujarati and Sanskrit. I just contributed by translating one such Gujarati rhymes 

ગુરુદેવના ચરણમાં કરીયે કરોડો વંદન 

into Sanskrit. Here it goes for the benefits of all readers of this blog "Express YourSelf !

गुरुदेवस्य पादयोः।           कुर्महे कोटि प्रणामान्
परब्रह्मन: पादयोः           कुर्महे कोटि प्रणामान्

भवसागरम् तारयन्त:           न: नाविका: भवन्त:
दीनबंधव: भो: रसवन्त:           कुर्महे कोटि प्रणामान्

वयम् दीन हीना: आगता:           न किमपि नीता:
भवद्भि:  ह्रदा  स्विकृता:            कुर्महे कोटि प्रणामान्

भो: श्री हरिसखीन:           श्रीजी सदृशा: प्रतापिन:
अन्तरे वसन्त: शाक्षिन :            कुर्महे कोटि प्रणामान्

भवन्त: अमृतम्  वर्षन्त:           तथापि वयम् पिपीषन्त:
परम् ह्रदया: रमन्त:            कुर्महे कोटि प्रणामान्

सदा नेत्रेषु वसन्तु              शरणे न: स्थापयन्तु 
वयम् पादयोः वसेम            कुर्महे कोटि प्रणामान्


I attended few sessions by Amazon about its Alexa devices, during last few months. Voice represents next major disruption in computing. These devices provides VUI (Voice User Interface). We had hands-on sessions and interactive QAs. Let me cover some of the relevant URLs and overview in this blog post for readers of "Express YourSelf !"


Here is a quick comparison of all major devices:

Echo Dot Echo Dot
Kids Edition
Echo Echo Plus Echo Spot Echo Show
Price Rs. 4000 N/A Rs. 10,000 Rs. 15000 Rs. 13000 N/A
$50 $80 $100 $150 $130 $230
Rs. 3341 Rs. 5346 Rs 6682 Rs. 10023 Rs.8687 Rs. 15369
Microphones 7 7 7 7 4 8
Misc. Smart hub 2.5" screen 7" screen

Apart from the regular devices from Amazon, few smart cars and smart TVs also have built-in Alexa support. Amazon also launched "Alexa 7-Mic Far-Field Dev Kit" that hardware can be part of any product. One can add display support also like Echo Spot and Echo Show, however it needs to go through rigorous certification process from Amazon.

Comparison of Mobile App with Alexa Skill

Mobile App ~ Alexa Skill
Mobile App icon ~ Invocation Name

Many mobile apps have Alexa skill e.g ola, goibibo, crickinfo, zomato etc. have alexa skill

How it works

Alexa software has mainly two major components

1. ASK (Alexa skills kit) to build new skill

2. AVS (Alexa voice service) to integrate with RPi kind of device. 

The hardware is quite simple with microphone array and speaker. The microphone array used for noise cancellation. The spoken sentence is divided into :

1. Wakeup word
2. launch
3. Invocation name. It should be two words. 
3. Utterance


step 1. Wake up word can be = Alexa / Computer / Echo / Amazon

This will wakeup the device. It triggered beam forming to listen. 

step 2. The utterance (captured audio) goes to cloud

step 3. At cloud real magic happens with

3.1 speech processing 
3.2 NLP

step 4. The invocation name  is detected. With invocation name, the execution flow goes to specific skill. Now skill has all the logic, algorithm to further understand the utterance, to access cloud service, database etc and finally for the response

Here the front-end is developed and tested with simulator using

step 5. As per training model, Alexa translate the utterance to Intent. The developer need to create custom intent, that mapped to function implementation to provide response. Alexa also provide standard built-in Intent, that developer can implement
There is a set of built-in intent libraries for various use cases

In Alexa terms "slot" is like argument to function. Alexa has built-in slot types :

There is many to one mapping between utterances and intent. There is one to one mapping between intent and function

There is many to one mapping between utterances and custom slot. There is one to one mapping between custom slot value and argument value to function. 
So one can pronounce "A.C" or "Air Conditioner" still it maps to same enumarated value as argument to function. Such synonymous are detected using "Entity Resolution" 

The back-end function can be implemented at any HTTPS terminated end-point or AWS lambda service. The AWS Lambda service, at present, is available only for regions: 
1. US east North vergina
2. EU (Ireland)

The professional skill can use session attribute for better user experience and also for data analytics. 

step 6. The response can be 
6.1 Speech : SSML, Local lingo, TTS, audio stream, small mp3 files
6.2 Cards = title, subtitle (skill name), text (content), image. 
Cards are optional. We can use rich text with different font including Unicode at card. It is built using various BodyTemplate and ListTemplate. 

The speech output goes to speaker. The card output goes to 
1. Alexa Companion App
2. Echo Spot and
3. Echo Show

One can check device capability for including card/video in response. 

The Alexa skill can be built using pre-built models

1. Custom: For unique need
2. Flash briefing : For RSS feed
3. Smart Home : For home automation
4. Video : For video application

Questions - Answers

Let me highlights few leanings about Alexa Echo eco-system and the devices

* The Alexa companion app can be connected to only one device. So it is not possible to push same image/content/card to all companion app running on mobile using single Alexa device
* Amazon allows to use same invocation word for multiple skill developed by same/different people. All such skill can be configured for given device. However the skill that is configured last, it will be invoked for the duplicate invocation word. 
* It is possible to enable/disable specific app on the device using mobile app
* It may possible to develop smart home device using Raspberry Pi for single user, with skill that is not published. One can use Smart Home pre-built model. Let the Intent invoke code running at Raspberry Pi, that turn on/off home appliances using GPIO pin and relay. 
* None of the Alexa devices has built-in battery. 
* "Alexa for Business" can have features like allowing access to very specific limited set of skills only. 
* Alexa does not have any adult content, so parental control is not needed. 
* One can change wakup word and replace "alexa". However still it will be female voice only. The Alexa devices do not support response in male voice. 
* Alexa device cannot be used for dictation or speech to text conversion. One can use AWS transcribe service for the same.  
* One can develop (1) one shot dialogue (2) multi-turn dialogue skills
* To design multi-turn dialogue skills, one can use (1) graph UI or (2) frame UI. 
* Alexa can prompt for missing slot
* Amazon is coming up with Notification, that will be triggered by skill to Alexa device. However until the end-user ask to get notifications, the Alexa device will not start talking by itself to inform about notification. 


Now, let's have a look to important URLs : Design of Voice Experience :Join the Amazon developer community & check in for the event in India. : It has details about all meetup, hackathon, webinar, slack channel etc.  and : Online learning resources and Getting started with skill development : Alexa public sample code repository Getting Started in India

Alexa response can be further enhanced at skill using

1. SSML. SSML is Speech Synthesis Markup Language. More details:

Alexa specific SSML :

2. Speechcon


Sohan Maheshwar

Distilled Python

Sometime back, I came across an excellent book on Python: "Fluent Python" (O'Reilly, 2015) by Luciano Ramalho. On Saturday, 28th April, I got opportunity to listen to him live at Geeknight workshop "Distilled Python: Features you must know to use it well" at Thoughtworks, Kormangala, Bangalore. Here is my note about the event, exclusive for readers of this blog: Express YourSelf !

He programms in Python since 1998. His speaking record includes PyCon US, OSCON, OSCON-EU, PythonBrasil, RuPy and an ACM Webinar. All the slidedecks are available at :

Generators and Iteration 

Generator allows lazy data processing. Here data is loaded to main memory, as and when needed. In Haskell programming language, almost everything is lazy data processing. At opposite, numpy Python module is about fast data processing. Here all data is loaded in memory for vector arithmetic. Intel introduced new instructions MMX (Multimedia eXtension) in mid 1990s. 

import sys
for arg in sys.argv:

print arg

Here is list of Python's built-in iterable objects and items they yield. 

  • str : unicode char
  • bytes: int 0 to 255
  • tuple : individual fields
  • dict: keys
  • set: elements
  • io.TextIOWrapper: Unicode lines
  • models.query.QuerySet : DB rows
  • numpy.ndarray : Multidimensional array , elements, rows 
Here are few use cases of Iterator in Python

Parallel Assignment is possible with iterable objects. 

It is also called tuple unpacking. However it is not specific to tuple. Here right side of = sign is iterable. 

pairs = [('a', 10), ('B', 20)]

for label, size in pairs: 
print(lable, '->', size)

Multiple values can be passed to function

This is also called star arguments. 

t = (3,4,5)
def fun(a, b, c):

Reduction functions:

We use "map-reduce" in Big Data. Python has support for "map-reduce" However such reduction functions server the purpose of "map-reduce" 
  • all : boolean 
  • any : boolean
  • max
  • min
  • sum
Reduction functions consume iterable and provide single result. 
Python has mapreduce. 

One can write more readable code, where multiple and conditions are replaced by all and multiple or conditions are replaced by any


sort() function only for sorting list. sort() sorts list in place. 

sorted(): a built in function. it consumes any iterable. It has keyword argument for sorting key

Here one can pass even function as argument. Unlike other sorting library in C/C++, here the function is not for comparison. It is about to generate key. 

To write poems, one needed words who ends with same characters. Here is source code. 

sorted(L, key=lambda s:list(reversed(s)))

Now let's have a look in details about iterator . Python has built-in support for iterator design pattern. There are two types of objects (1) Iterable (2) Iterator. 

Like food is etable, a collections of objects are iterables. iterable has methods like  __iter__ 

The iterator has state. It has methods like  __next__

Please note, the next method is not part of iterable object, as it can be shared by multiple threads. 

StopIteration excpetion raised by next() method. 

in python "for loop" obtains iterator from iterable. Then it repeatedly invokes next() on iterator. 

Now something about generator. In Python, generator is like synonymous of iterator, and can be used interchangeably, but they both are different. In Python its syntax is same as normal function. The generator is also defined with "def" keyword like function. However only generator contains "yield" keyword somewhere in code. 

One should not invoke __iter__, __next__ method directly. Here, Python acts like framework. So developer will not invoke those methods, but let Python as a framework invokes them, as and when needed. The developer can create our own dender methods __next__, __iter__ etc. in object. next(g) is implemented in optimized way in C language. 

In generator the execution flow is frozen at "yield" keyword and it gets resume later. So it is synchronize progrmaming without call back. So generator is introduced in JavaScript also. Please note, here "yield" is not same as "return" in function. The generator cannot be reset. 

Built-in generators of Python 
  • enumerate : returns first is number which increments and second is as per the input
  • filter: Python2 returns list. in Python3 one can go over data that does not fit in memory, using "filter" generator. 
  • map
  • reversed
  • zip: consumes iterables and generate tuple. if one iterable is shorter than zip will stop at shortest without any exception. In Python2 zip generator returns tuples that can be passed to list() constructor. it can be passed to dict() also. 
Now let's see about Generator expression (genex) in Python

1. list comprehesnsion
it is inspired from "Set builder notation" in Maths and Haskell programming language. 

l = [ord(c) for c in s]

Here "ord" function gives ASCII value for given character. The output is always a list. 

g = (ord(c) for c in s)
it returns generator with laziness. 

To understand more, please refer 

This project is no where link with ISIS terrorist group :-) . In this project, instead of writing complex for loop content, the generator expressions and generators are effectively used. This code is about database migration with many command line options in main function. It captures inputs from one DB and kept it in generator for lazy evaluation. The output generator is populated by processing data from that input generator

pytest module

The post lunch session focused on TDD (Test Driven Development). Using pytest module, we can have test cases (TCs) without class. In Java, JUnit framework requires class to write TCs. So JUnit, CppUnit etc. Unit test framework are not Pythonic way. 

pytest.raise provides context manager. It has its own entry and exit method. It can be used to lock/unlock shared resources and open/close the file. 

@pytest.fixture is more like meta-data programming. Here fixture function is passed as argument to test function. 

There are many plug-ins to generate fancy reports on top of pytest. 

Python Data Model

Python Data model is not about data science. The better name can be Python Object model. It is all about various dunder methods to support many built-in feature of Python as framework. These dunder method should be implemented at user-defined class. Such methods are like new and delete methods in C++. The dunder methods are not protected method, even pycharm IDE indicates as private/protected, by mistake.method with __ as prefix is private/protected. If __ is as prefix and suffix both, then such method is dunder method. 

1. In Python all object should have method for string representation. Python have two dunder methods repr and str. The str method is invoked by print() for string represntation of the object. The repr method is invoked for debugging the object. 

Bobby Woolf inspired to add repr method to Python data model. The reprlib is very useful module to implement repr dunder method for user-defined class. For example if we use reprlib.repr for our own vector class, then it will (1) remove infinite loop from collection member variable and (2) it will print first 10 members only 

2. collection should have length

3. The iterable object should have method iter

4. The iterator method should have method next

5. The eq method is called for == operator. 

6. The init method in Python is not constructor. It is inializaer. It does not allocate memory.

7. The getitem method is very useful for indexing and slicing. 

Let's look at genex in few dunder methods for Vector class. 

def __eq__(self, other):
    return all(a == b for a, v, in zip(self, other))

This method will incorrectly, return True, if both vectors have different length and initial members are identical. We can use izip in place of zip. However, the better solution is, first compare length. 

def __abs__(self, other):
     return math.sqrt(sum(x*X for x in self))

Here are use cases, when Python invokes these dunder methods

1. arithmetic and Boolean expressions : operator overloading
2. impicit conversion to str e.g.  print(x)
3. conversion to bool when used if, while, and, or, not
4. attribute access, including dynamic or virtual attributes
5. emulating collections: o[k], k in o, len(o)
6. Iteration : for, tuple unpacking, star arguments etc. 
7. Context managers - with blocks
8. meta programming: attribute descriptors, meta classes. 

Then we had nice discussion about implementing __rmul__ method to implement product of scalar and vector, where both arguments can be in any sequence. The use of returning "NotImplemented" to invoke rmul. Even in all standard Python 3.8 libraries also we may not get implementation of __rmul__ method for any class. 


Type codeC TypePython TypeMinimum size in bytes
'b'signed charint1
'B'unsigned charint1
'u'Py_UNICODEUnicode character2 (see note)
'h'signed shortint2
'H'unsigned shortint2
'i'signed intint2
'I'unsigned intlong2
'l'signed longint4
'L'unsigned longlong4


coroutines is another nice Python feature. We can use keyword async along with coroutines. As per David Beazley's advice: coroutines are not for generators. 

We should use exact same error message as Python reports, in our custom class, so one use the error message in stack overflow searching :-)

fractions.Fractions is vary useful module, who stores numerator and denominator separately.  

Head First Design Patterns is another book similar to GoF Design Patterns 

Python is easy to use and very popular so investing your time and efforts in Python learning, gives fast returns. 

Jaydeep - the event organizer stressed upon, various plugins for pytest module, to generate test automation fancy reports for people at different hierarchy. Here is one such module at his github repository :

About various programming languages

Go and Python: Both progrmmaing languages allow to write code without using class. On other hand, in Java Maths class has only static methods, yet class is needed. 

Python understands iteration, better than C. In C, programming, index variable i is needed. It is not needed in Python since 1991. Since 2004, Java also does not need i. This is borrowed from CLU language by Barbara Liskov. CLU language was not commercially successful but it influenced many programming languages. C does not have iterable object. Go : limited set of iterable objects. One cannot create iterable objects in Go language. :-(

"0" is true in Python. It is true in C also. As it contains a string with '0' = 0x30 character. However "0" is false in JavaScript

In other languages, exception indicates abnormal error condition. While in Python to raise signal also, exception is used. So the generator are introduced in JavaScript also. 

Object Oriented Programming are design patterns for non-OOP languages. As we know, Iterator is design pattern for OOP languages, except Python. Python has built-in support for iterator design pattern. 

In Python the number overflow never happen, unlike other programming languages. The variable is automatically promoted to data type with next higher level of memory allocated. 

The Python module "itertools" is inspired by Haskell programming language. If you have not used "itertools" module, then most likely you might have written code, that was unnecessary. Few example of itertools: 
  • infinite generators
count(), cycle(), repeat()
  • generators that consume multiple iterables
chain(), tee(), izip(), imap(), product(), compress()
  • generators that filter or bundle items
compress(), dropwhile(), groupby(), ifilter(), islice()
  • generators that rearrange items
product(), permutations(), combinations()

"I have a problem. So let me use 'regular expression'."
"Now you will have two problems" :-)
Python has built-in most useful functions that does not need use regular expression. E.g. endswith() 

The generators can be implemented in C language. We can use "static" keyword, so local variables inside functions can retain the previous values as state of iterator. 

OOP language like Java, suggest to make attributes as private and then add getters and setters methods for them. The IDEs have support to write such methods automatically. In Python, by default the attributes are public. If needed, they can be converted as private property, and it does not impact the existing code. 

"Pythonic" is a new idiom. Let's see example of Pythonic API. Python has built-in urlib2 library. However, developing HTTP based client using urlib2 is less readable comparing developing the same using "requests" module. "requests" module is like "HTTP for humans". People talks a lot bout UI and UX. Python also focus on DX. DX means Developers' eXperience.  Have a look to these workshops about Pythonic APIs

The creator of Java programming language, wanted "inheritance" should be out of Java language. Julia is programming language for data science. Julia and Go, both programming languages do not support inheritance. 

Java and Python both have object member 'self' for all the member functions as an argument. 

The "language reference" document can be first place to understand any programming language. However, one may find "Python language reference" document as dry one. 

Key take away point: If you have not used "itertools" module, then most likely you might have written code, that was unnecessary. So study features of itertools Python module. 


Twitter : @ramalhoorg
E-mail :